Main Page Main Page
A Journal for and by the Readers of C.J. Cherryh
Felines and Ferocious Allegiance: A Comparison of The Pride of Chanur and Foreigner
By Sabina Betschke
Phoenix  Sabina BetschkeCaroline Janice Cherryh is known in the science fiction realms for her inventive stories and truly alien aliens. She has won the Hugo Award for her provoking novels Dowbelow Station and Cyteen. Yet Cyteen is not the only book of interest she has written in her long career; among the over fifty books she wrote are The Pride of Chanur and Foreigner. Both books seem, if only skimmed, very much alike in their set up, but a closer look will reveal a plethora of differences which affect the story, such as the locations and the intriguing species she so believable conjures.

The two books are similar in some ways. Both are set in a distant future with advanced technology and, as such, have to be counted as science fiction. Both  feature contact between aliens and humans, or contact by one human with a group of aliens. Tully, the human in The Pride of Chanur and Bren, the human in Foreigner, are both isolated from humanity and have to manage on their own in situations that could cause their death any minute, with beings that don't feel at all like humans or understand them at first.

Despite the similarities, each novel has its one unique location to draw the reader in. The Pride of Chanur is almost exclusively set in space, whereas Foreigner takes place upon a planet. The two settings on their own make for different hazards and necessities of behaviour. Aboard a ship or space station one has to be careful of blown air seals and pressure drops, while on a planet harsh weather and the native fauna and flora can be lethal. The stories are even more unlike if one looks at the main locations. On the one hand, there is The Pride of Chanur, a tight, narrow ship running at its technical limits; on the other, there is Malguri, a fortress several millennia old without any modern technology.

Another area where the books differ are the main alien species. The hani as main characters in The Pride of Chanur are best described as humanoid lions. The males are fighting hand to hand for territories supported by the females; since males can't stand each other and start fighting each other on the spot, political deals are mostly made by the females who represent each clan. In contrast, the atevi will follow a leader no matter the gender and usually avoid any kind of quarrel. Unlike the hani that do understand friendship, the atevi know only man'chi as grouping instinct and are bewildered by declaration of liking, which to them only applies to salad.

Although both books have similarities, the differences outweigh them in these pleasurable reads. One can't say that one is based upon the other or re-tells it with different characters. The two books create their own universes, as one expects from Cherryh books. The background and characters take a different view on the matter of first contact. Each of them is a good story in its own right, and neither should be judged superior over the other.

Artwork:  "Phoenix" © Sabina Betschke

Back to Main Page